IcoTherm Outperforms Guardian in Conservatory Warm Roofs?

11 min read Conservatories


Welcome to our comprehensive exploration of conservatory warm roof systems, specifically focusing on two prominent contenders in the market: IcoTherm and Guardian. A warm roof system is much more than a mere architectural element; it plays a pivotal role in enhancing the energy efficiency, comfort, and overall aesthetic appeal of your conservatory. Both IcoTherm and Guardian are renowned for their unique features and benefits, but understanding their distinct differences is crucial for homeowners looking to make an educated decision. In this detailed guide, we delve into the intricate aspects of each system, shedding light on why IcoTherm might emerge as the superior option for enhancing your home.

Warm roofs have revolutionised how we perceive conservatory spaces, transcending the traditional role of a roof. By seamlessly blending functionality with style, these innovative roofing solutions offer a transformative impact on conservatories, turning them into year-round havens of comfort and efficiency. As we navigate through the IcoTherm and Guardian systems, our goal is to equip you with all the necessary information, allowing you to discern which system aligns best with your specific needs and preferences. Whether it’s the nuances of energy conservation, the subtleties of architectural design, or the practicalities of installation, our comprehensive analysis will unveil the critical factors that set these systems apart. So, let’s uncover the key elements that make IcoTherm a potentially more advantageous choice for your conservatory.

Understanding Warm Roofs

Conservatory warm roofs represent a significant advancement in roofing technology, especially in the context of conservatories. Unlike traditional roofing systems, warm roofs are designed with a focus on insulation and energy efficiency. At the heart of their design is the principle of thermal regulation, which ensures that heat loss is minimised, maintaining a comfortable temperature within the conservatory throughout the year.

The structure of a warm roof is a key differentiator. Typically, it consists of an insulating layer above the rafters, ensuring that the entire roof structure is kept at a near room temperature. This design contrasts sharply with that of cold roofs, where the insulation is placed below the rafters, often leading to heat loss and inefficiency.

One of the primary benefits of a warm roof is its ability to conserve energy. By providing superior insulation, warm roofs reduce the need for excessive heating in winter and cooling in summer, leading to significant energy savings. This efficiency not only has a positive impact on your utility bills but also contributes to a reduced carbon footprint, making it an environmentally conscious choice.

Comfort is another pivotal advantage of warm roofs. They create a stable and comfortable environment within the conservatory, free from the extremes of temperature fluctuations. This consistent comfort transforms the conservatory into a versatile living space, usable throughout the different seasons.

Conservatory warm roof Icotherm

In terms of enhancing property value, warm roofs are a lucrative addition. Their modern and efficient design not only elevates the aesthetic appeal of the conservatory but also makes it more functional and appealing to potential buyers. The added insulation and improved energy efficiency are attractive features in the real estate market.

When comparing warm roofs to cold roofs, several factors come into play. In colder climates, the benefits of a warm roof are particularly pronounced, providing much-needed insulation and warmth. For conservatories intended for year-round use, the warm roof is undoubtedly the preferable option, offering consistent comfort and usability. Budget considerations also play a role; while warm roofs might have a higher initial cost, their long-term energy savings and durability often justify the investment. Additionally, the size of the conservatory influences the choice; larger spaces particularly benefit from the stable temperatures provided by warm roofs.

In summary, the decision between a warm and a cold roof hinges on various factors, including climate, usage, budget, and conservatory size. Understanding these aspects is crucial in selecting the right roofing system for your conservatory, ensuring it meets your needs for comfort, efficiency, and style.

Conservatory warm roof Icotherm

IcoTherm Warm Roof System: An In-Depth Look

The IcoTherm Warm Roof System stands as a paragon of modern roofing technology, blending impeccable design, superior materials, and remarkable energy efficiency. This deep dive into the IcoTherm system will explore its construction, materials, technical specifications, and the unique benefits it offers.

Construction and Materials

At the core of IcoTherm’s construction is a commitment to robustness and longevity. The system employs high-quality materials, ensuring a sturdy and durable structure. The use of advanced insulation materials is a cornerstone of IcoTherm’s design. This insulation not only enhances the thermal efficiency of the roof but also contributes to its overall strength and durability.

The technical prowess of IcoTherm is evident in its impressive U-values, which can go as low as 0.13. These values signify exceptional thermal resistance, ensuring minimal heat loss during colder months and reduced heat gain during warmer seasons. This level of insulation efficiency is a standout feature, setting IcoTherm apart in the market.

Conservatory warm roof Icotherm Surrey

Styles and Customisation

Diversity in design is another forte of the IcoTherm system. With options like Icoview and Icospan, homeowners can choose a style that best compliments their property’s architecture. Icoview offers an inline design with full-height glass panels, perfect for those seeking a contemporary look with ample natural light. Icospan, on the other hand, is an ideal choice for orangeries, offering either a standard flat roof or a sophisticated Sheerline roof lantern.

The system’s customisation options extend beyond aesthetic choices. Homeowners can select from various insulation thicknesses, tile types, and finishes, tailoring the roof to their specific needs and preferences.

Environmental Considerations

Environmental responsibility is a key aspect of the IcoTherm philosophy. The system utilises fully recyclable EPS insulation and FSC certified timber, reflecting a commitment to sustainability. This eco-friendly approach not only reduces the ecological footprint of the roofing process but also appeals to environmentally conscious consumers.

Conservatory warm roof Icotherm Surrey

Durability and Warranty

Durability is a hallmark of the IcoTherm system. The robust construction and high-quality materials ensure that the roof can withstand the test of time and elements. This durability is underlined by a 25-year warranty, offering homeowners peace of mind and assurance of the product’s longevity.

Customer Testimonials and Case Studies

Real-world applications of the IcoTherm system have yielded numerous positive testimonials and case studies. Customers frequently praise the system for its energy efficiency, aesthetic appeal, and the significant improvement it brings to their living spaces. These endorsements are a testament to the system’s performance and the satisfaction it delivers to users.

Conservatory warm roof Icotherm Surrey

Guardian Warm Roof System: An Overview

The Guardian Warm Roof System is a noteworthy contender in the roofing industry, known for its innovative design, high-quality materials, and effective energy-saving features.

Design Features

Guardian’s design is centred around practicality and aesthetic appeal. The system’s construction incorporates advanced materials that not only contribute to its visual charm but also enhance its functional capabilities. The design is tailored to blend seamlessly with various architectural styles, making it a versatile choice for different types of properties

Material Quality

The Guardian system employs materials that strike a balance between durability and lightweight construction. This blend ensures that the roof is not only strong and capable of withstanding various weather conditions but also light enough to be compatible with a wide range of existing frames. This consideration is crucial for homeowners looking to upgrade their conservatories without extensive structural modifications.

Installation Process

One of the Guardian system’s most significant advantages is its straightforward and efficient installation process. Designed to be fitted quickly and with minimal disruption, the Guardian roof transforms conservatories in a relatively short time frame. This ease of installation is a huge plus for homeowners who desire a swift upgrade to their living space.

Energy Efficiency

Energy efficiency is at the forefront of the Guardian system’s benefits. By providing excellent insulation, the roof plays a pivotal role in reducing energy consumption. This efficiency is not only beneficial for the environment but also translates into cost savings for the homeowner, making it an economically attractive option.

Unique Selling Points

The Guardian system stands out for its ability to merge functionality with aesthetics seamlessly. Its design flexibility allows it to adapt to various conservatory styles, ensuring that the end result is both practical and visually appealing. Furthermore, the system’s compatibility with existing conservatory frames makes it a good choice for roof replacements.

Customer Experiences and Feedback

Feedback from users of the Guardian system often highlights its transformative impact on conservatories, turning them into comfortable, year-round spaces. Customers appreciate the enhanced thermal efficiency and the aesthetic upgrade it brings to their homes. These experiences underline the system’s reliability and effectiveness in delivering on its promises.


In summary, the Guardian Warm Roof System presents itself as a reliable, efficient, and aesthetically pleasing roofing solution. Its combination of easy installation, energy efficiency, and design versatility makes it a strong contender in the warm roof market.

Comparative Analysis: IcoTherm vs Guardian

When it comes to choosing the right warm roof system for your conservatory, the decision often boils down to a comparison between two leading options: IcoTherm and Guardian. This segment aims to provide a detailed analysis of both systems, focusing on their thermal efficiency, design flexibility, material quality, installation ease, and overall value.


Thermal Efficiency

– IcoTherm: Known for its exceptional thermal performance, the IcoTherm system boasts U-values as low as 0.13. This level of insulation is exemplary, ensuring minimal heat loss and maximum energy conservation.

– Guardian: While the Guardian system is also designed for energy efficiency, it does not specify U-values as low as IcoTherm, which suggests a difference in insulation performance.


Design Flexibility

– IcoTherm: Offers a range of styles, including Icoview and Icospan, allowing customization to suit various architectural tastes and requirements.

– Guardian: Also provides design flexibility, but the options and range may not be as extensive as IcoTherm’s.


Material Quality

– IcoTherm: Uses high-quality, sustainable materials including fully recyclable insulation and FSC certified timber.

– Guardian: Known for its robust and lightweight construction, but there’s less emphasis on the sustainability of materials.


Installation Ease

– IcoTherm: Designed for quick and easy installation, minimising disruption and time.

– Guardian: Also praised for its efficient installation process, making it a viable option for quick conservatory upgrades.

In summary, while both systems have their strengths, IcoTherm’s superior insulation, design versatility, commitment to sustainability, and extended warranty make it a more preferable choice in many scenarios.


After a comprehensive comparison, it’s clear that IcoTherm stands out as the superior warm roof system. Its outstanding insulation capabilities, bespoke design options, sustainability commitment, and long-term durability place it ahead of the competition. These features not only offer immediate benefits like energy savings and enhanced aesthetics but also promise long-term advantages in terms of property value and living comfort. IcoTherm represents a smart investment for homeowners seeking quality, efficiency, and style in their conservatory roofing.

Final Thoughts

For those contemplating an upgrade to their conservatory, the IcoTherm warm roof system emerges as a wise choice. Its blend of efficiency, design, and sustainability is hard to overlook. We encourage readers to explore these benefits in more detail. Visit our showroom, consult with our experts, and see firsthand how the IcoTherm system can transform your conservatory. Make a decision that brings lasting value and comfort to your home.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do conservatory warm roof improve energy efficiency?

Warm roofs improve energy efficiency by providing superior insulation. This reduces heat loss during colder months and minimises heat gain during warmer seasons, leading to lower energy bills and a more comfortable living environment.

Can IcoTherm and Guardian roofs be customised to fit any conservatory design?

Yes, both IcoTherm and Guardian offer customisation options. IcoTherm, in particular, provides a wide range of styles like Icoview and Icospan, allowing for greater flexibility to match different architectural designs.

What makes IcoTherm’s materials sustainable?

IcoTherm uses fully recyclable EPS insulation and FSC certified timber, emphasising environmental responsibility. These sustainable materials reduce the ecological footprint and appeal to environmentally conscious consumers.

How long do these warm roof systems last?

Both systems are designed for longevity. IcoTherm, for example, comes with a 25-year warranty, indicating its long-term durability.

Are warm roofs suitable for all climates?

Warm roofs are especially beneficial in colder climates due to their superior insulation. However, they are also effective in maintaining comfortable temperatures in various weather conditions, making them suitable for a wide range of climates.

Is the installation process disruptive?

Both IcoTherm and Guardian systems are designed for efficient installation. IcoTherm, in particular, emphasises minimal disruption, allowing for a quick and easy upgrade.

payment payment

Get A Quote

One of our team would be happy to have a chat with you about your requirements, answer any unanswered questions and measure up at a time that suits you to provide you a free, no obligation quote.

Get A Quote
feedback feedback

Our customers say

“It is no wonder that Sheerwater Glass are one of the oldest and most trusted companies in the Woking area.”John Coleman
View more reviews on Which?
location location

Areas we cover

Sheerwater Glass provides window installation and repairs throughout Surrey and the surrounding areas of our Woking showroom. If you’re interested in our services, we encourage you to check if we serve customers in your area by simply typing in your postcode.

If you check and find that we don’t serve customers in your area, in some cases, we may be able to help. Please call us to find out more.

Check your postcode